The Construction of Space Shuttle Launch Complex 39-B
A very personal and technical written and photographic history, by James MacLaren.
Page 68: Intertank Access Arm Lift plus How The FSS Came To Be, and More Hydrogen Than You Can Stand,
with Maybe Just a Little Bit of Art, Aesthetics, and Ballsy Ironworking Down near the Bottom.
We have already lifted the OMS Pods Heated Purge Covers, the GOX Arm Strongback, the OMBUU, and the GOX Arm and its Vent Hood. We are now deeply into that part of the contract where we were continuing to lift various large and complex pieces of GFE (Government Furnished Equipment) and hang them on the towers, and today we're going to lift the heaviest piece of all, the External Tank Gaseous Hydrogen Vent Arm, which was also known as the
Intertank
Access
Arm, and which was invariably referred to out on the Pad strictly by its acronym, the
IAA.
And, weirdly enough, the actual
Arm part of this monstrosity (which is the part that hangs on
hinges and actually
swings as all good "swing arms" do), was
not included in the Lift this day. That
Swing Arm is attached directly to
this thing, and when it's folded back out of the way, not being used, it lives over a kind of "balcony" or maybe a sort of a "porch" or something, and that part of things sticks out away from the main body of this beast, running along its length midway between its top and bottom, and you can
see it in our photograph, but of course,
structural steel works hard to hide things, even when we're looking directly at them in plain sight... but it's there, and you can see it. But the Swing Arm itself
isn't there, and it didn't show up until a fair bit later on.
The
Swing Arm part of things was
much smaller than the ridiculously
way-too-big contraption you see in the image above (and for the love of god, I've lived in goddamned
apartment buildings that were
smaller than this particular drug-induced hallucination), and I never got a chance to photograph them lifting that part of the IAA
system, and bolting it on to
this thing, because the work at Pad 41, more and more, and
more, was taking me away from activities on Pad B, and there was
much that I missed as a result.
And before we can understand the
Lift, we need to understand the thing that was getting
lifted, and to understand what's getting lifted in our photograph above these words, we're going to have to back away from it, and use a pair of isometric views of it, to kind of see what's going on in the photograph.
First, we'll look at an isometric view, which shows us the whole thing, fully-assembled, hanging off the northeast corner of the FSS, protruding outward an
alarming distance toward the Space Shuttle, of which all they're showing us is a section of the External Tank, but it does so in a less-than-fully-helpful way.
So here's
79K24048 sheet M-335, plain, without any colors or labels to help you understand what you're seeing. All that's been done to this image is the
rectification, which seeks to straighten out (as much as possible, which is a very
limited thing) the lines by removing the distortions which come with the original image I'm forced to work with. And when you look at the drawing
border, you can
immediately see that in order to render the
contents of the drawing as straight and true
as possible, the border went to hell and wound up
unstraight and
untrue, but such is life. But that's all that's been done to it. Nothing else. Plain vanilla all the way, baby.
But that's not very satisfying, and it doesn't really give you a proper feel for where we
really are in any kind of accurate way, and we're gonna mark it up some, to give you a somewhat better feel for exactly where you are, and exactly what you're looking at, using that same drawing, M-335, to do it.
So here's
79K24048 sheet M-335 colored and labeled to let you see the main players, RSS, FSS, IAA, and ET, with each one labeled.
I'll leave it as an exercise to you the reader to find the little Lego Minifig looking guy that whoever was on the
drafting board this day decided to include as perhaps a bit of reference for the scale of things, and then I'll further leave it as an exercise for you to consider how our little Minifig was actually
rendered, vis-à-vis the handrail they appear to have their left hand resting upon the top runner of, which would appear to place that top runner near neck-level with them, and then remember that those top runners were
OSHA mandated at 3'-6" to the
top edge of the 1½"Ø schedule forty steel pipe, above the flooring they were guarding the edges of, and maybe take a guess at how tall, or perhaps
short, our little Minifig person actually
is. And in case you doubt me with the use of the
top runner, the intermediate handrail runner is exactly waist level on our Minifig Guy, and those intermediate runners were also OSHA mandated, at 1'-8" on-center above the flooring they guarded.
These are hard numbers without margin or wiggle room for moving stuff around. They
is what they is, and they
ain't nothing more nor nothing less. Engineering drafting and the human form, for some odd reason, never seem to go together, and if somebody is good at one, they tend to be poor at the other, and our drawing packages reflect this sort of thing in too many places to enumerate, and... I've always wondered...
why?
But even when M-335 is colored and labeled, it
still doesn't match our
photograph and to get to the bottom of
that, we're going to have to return to a drawing I showed you on the previous page, sort of in passing, and once we've looked at that drawing, we might have to
combine the two, into yet another
Frankendrawing, as I've been forced into doing a few times previously, in this narrative.
And
79K24048 sheet M-336, which you've already encountered, when
I drew your attention to this end of things on the previous page, is where we're going to take a large portion of Frankenstein's Monster, and graft it on to the rest of the creature, in the hope that it will allow you to better understand what the fuck it is that's
really going on with our Lift.
And when you combine the two drawings together, and you get yourself a nice
79K24048 sheet M-335-336 Frankendrawing.
And with the Frankendrawing, the stupid Swing Arm is no longer there, getting in the way and confusing the issue, nor is any of the rest of the Hinge and Latchback
apparatus, and now we stand a fighting chance of actually
understanding what the fuck we're going to be
looking at, in the coming series of photographs.
Yes, it contains clearly-visible
inaccuracies and distortions, and I'm fully aware of that, and the time and effort required to
completely eradicate that stuff when pasting
the body of the beast onto its new background struck me as unreasonable, so I just kind of swiped at it, and decided "That's good enough," and moved on. Warts and all, it
gets the job done, and that's all I care about, ok? It lets you see how this crap all fits together, as it existed on the day we
Lifted the goddamned thing. And I didn't bother to
clean it up elsewhere all too very much, either, and the Frankendrawing still has some original black-line labels to things that no longer exist on it, and I left those original black-line labels there, to let you know there's
more to this thing, than meets the eye on the Frankendrawing. Feel free to go back to the
unaltered version of M-335 if you'd like to continue admiring that stuff. Whatever. I don't give a shit.
Except, of course, that it's never going to be
that easy, and you'll notice I took the time and trouble to highlight and label the IAA
Support Structure on the FSS, and that was for a
reason, and the reason is because it's what holds the whole nightmare
schmutz up in the air, and maybe we'd best step back away from things
yet again, and give
this thing the attention it is so very much worthy of, because, hey, it's what they're gonna be
bolting this motherfucker
on to, once they get it up in the air, and...
It's kind of interesting on its own, anyway, and we're here, so...
...ok.
And waaay back on
Page 14 is where you
first were shown the Support Structure, but back then you were very young, and very new with this stuff, and I just sort of waved at it as we went by, and did not overburden you with it at the time.
But now...
...it's
time.
So. To review,
here's north side of the whole FSS (Side 4), viewed from an unusual location (I've never found so much as a
single other image, taken by anybody, taken at any time, looking at it from this viewpoint) behind and beyond the 9099 Building on the concrete of the Pad Deck, kind of over by the LOX Tower, but out and away from it to the northwest, some.
And here's a
reduced-scale version of that same image, Image 013, with the IAA Support Structure highlighted.
And back in the
very beginning, before the FSS became an FSS and was instead a
LUT, this area, extending down from the top of the tower one hundred feet on Side 4 of that LUT, was bare, and our IAA Support Structure did not exist.
We can look at
Side 1 and Side 4 of the original LUT in 75M05121 sheet 1, which is the
cover sheet for the whole works (despite the weird-ass fact that the
structural drawings for the LUT carried a 75M number that was one digit
lower), as designed and built by von Braun and Crew, and there is not the slightest hint of any kind of any thing where the IAA Support Structure appeared, nearly 20 years later.
Observe.
75M05120 sheet 46 for Sides 1 and 2 of the original LUT.
And
75M05120 sheet 47 for Sides 3 and 4 of the original LUT. And of course it's
Side 4 where we will find our IAA Support Structure on the FSS at Pad B, although, when looking at either Side 1 or Side 3, it will
also be visible, hanging off of the side of the tower.
So we return once again to the present part of the narrative, and we see on
79K10338 sheet S-53, where Wilhoit added Sheffield's
steel to the FSS, to create a
Support Structure which would, some future day, be able to carry the quite-substantial load of the Intertank Access Arm.
And just for fun, we'll harken back to Apollo Days one more time, and I'll give you a look at
75M05120 sheet 46 with the future IAA Support Structure grafted on to the original LUT, so as you can see how it all fits together in the Greater Scheme of Things.
And in our photograph above these words, we can see what a
monster that goddamned IAA is, and yet, when we look at where it would fit in on the original LUT, all of a sudden it gets kind of
puny, and you give that one a little thought, and you suddenly realize, "Holy FUCK, that goddamned LUT is
gigantic," and... you're absolutely right. That goddamned LUT is
gigantic. And it rolls around across the countryside like somebody's little red wagon, and... Jeesus FUCK! What the hell were these people
thinking when they first
built this shit?
Also, look close, and where the IAA Support Structure makes actual
contact with the LUT, I've had to
fade the IAA Support Structure overlay a little bit, and that's because it comes in to the actual
Primary Framing a little bit
behind what they're calling the "Umbilical Arm Support Col." and this will be the best place I'll ever get to draw your attention to the fact that what we've been calling "Strongbacks" for our FSS Swing Arms, was originally an "Umbilical Arm Support Col." on the LUT, and the damn thing runs
full height of the whole LUT, and I have a sneaking suspicion that when they designed and built this stuff, they
weren't quite sure about
exactly where their Swing Arms would wind up being located, and to give themselves the requisite
forgiveness, they just ran the damn Strongback
full height, and that way, if the
Vehicle (the
Moon Rocket) changed in some way, or the business of getting stuff into it through the
Umbilicals changed in some way, no worries, we'll just move the goddamned Swing Arm up, or down, or thicker, or thinner, or whatever, and our nice
tower will permit us to do so.
Which is kind of cool, if you ask me.
Those people were
sharp, and that sharpness gets manifested in
so very many different ways, most of which you'd never notice, until you really start
digging in with this stuff.
And of course, over on the other side of the tower, what they're calling an "Umbilical Arm Locking Col." is what we've been calling the Latchback Strongbacks, and the same deal applies over there, with regards to
Full Height Forgiveness.
So... yeah.
Except that...
Is anybody out there... wondering?
Wondering
why the location I just gave you for where the
future IAA Support Structure would
connect with the existing steel of the original LUT... seems to be a little... off?
Seems like it's a pretty good ways
down from the top, isn't it?
On the
FSS, which we saw in 79K10338 sheet S-53, the top of the Support Structure is only 80 feet below the top of the tower. Only four Tower Levels down.
But on the
LUT, which we saw in my doctored-up copy of 75M05120 sheet 46, the top of the same Support Structure which I placed in there is
140 feet below the top of the tower. Which is
seven tower levels down.
So what gives?
And herein lies another tale within a tale, and herein we find ourselves
stepping back yet again, and this time we're gonna step back all the way to the time when Wilhoit built NASA a nice
FSS to put on top of their Launch Pad, so as they could start launching
Space Shuttles instead of Saturn V's.
Which was
just before I first showed up out there, as Sheffield Steel's brand-new
answering machine which they were compelled to install in their
field trailer out at the Pad, by Pat Costello, who was the Frank Briscoe Company's
Project Manager, because he was
sick and tired of not being able to reach Dick Walls, who was Sheffield Steel's
Project Manager, and who was also
subcontracted to Briscoe, and if they wanted to get
paid for the work they did, they
might want to play nice with Pat Costello, which of course they
did, even though the
answering machine cost them a few more dollars per week in
overhead costs than they would have
liked to spend... but oh well.
And this is
reallly late in the game for me to be digging into the
details of How The FSS Got Built, but
I have not, to this point, told you very much more about it other than the fact that the FSS is a repurposed LUT, and that sounds simple enough, and I've chosen to let it go, up till now, but...
...as a really cool lady I know who conducted the orchestra at Carnegie Hall a few times in her younger days was so fond of saying...
...Ancora una volta da capo al fine!
And there's a little more to it than you might
imagine, so...
...here we go. Again.
The FSS is 250 feet tall.
Ok, fine.
And the LUT (just the tower portion of things, not including the Box) is 380 feet tall.
Ok, fine.
But the bottom of the LUT has a funny angled look to it, and the squarely-rectangular portion of the LUT is "only" 320 feet tall.
Ok, ok. Fine, fine.
And you look at the FSS, and you see a nice Hammerhead Crane on top of it, and you look at the LUT, and you see the very
same Hammerhead Crane on top of it, and you very reasonably surmise... "Ok, so they cut the
top off the goddamned thing, and stuck it down into the concrete of the Pad Deck, and okey dokey, fine and dandy, here you go, NASA, here's your nice new FSS."
Except...
If you were to make that
surmise, you'd be
WRONG.
Remember children...
...
nothing is ever easy out here, right?
Right.
So.
What
did they do?
And for that, we'll return to the drawings we've already seen, and I'll toss an extra one in there too, along with a few photographs, and in that way, you will be caused to properly
understand How The FSS Came To Be.
We'll go right to the heart of the matter, and start with the
smoking gun, which we've already seen,
79K10338 sheet S-53, but this time I've highlighted it differently and maybe take note of how the
relationship between the pink and yellow highlighted numbers takes a pretty radical
jump up near the tippytop of the tower. And then look at Note 2, down at the very bottom of the drawing.
Son of a bitch, wouldja lookit that!
They
excised 60 feet of that LUT, but they did it in a way that would allow them to keep the
very top of it, with the Hammerhead Crane and the Elevator Machine Room on the level beneath it included for re-use, while at
the same time also keeping the
bottom, the
strongest part of it, too!
Look
close, at the weights of the Primary Framing Columns on S-53 for the Column that runs from FSS Elevation 260'-0" to 280'-0" and then compare it with the weight of the Column sitting
directly underneath it, running from FSS Elevation 240'-0" to 260'-0".
The topmost portion of that FSS Column, which runs from 20 feet below the top of the tower at 280'-0" down to 40 feet below the top of the tower at 260'-0", is a W14x
61.
And spliced
directly underneath it, running the next 20 feet downward, it becomes a W14x
193, and below
that it quits being a W Shape altogether and changes into a Box Column made out of 1" thick steel plate which has been welded together.
Right there, immediately beneath that Column Splice just above the FSS 260'-0" Elevation floor steel, things all of a sudden get
a lot stronger.
And we return to Apollo drawing package
75M05120, and we look at a marked-up copy of Sheet
54, and there you go, there it all is, complete with correctly-matching Column Weights and everything tra la la.
And then, once you know how that shit works on the
engineering drawings, you get to look at some of the old photographs, and all that we have left is for Pad A, but they'll do, and you get to see them with New Eyes, and maybe, just maybe, a tiny bit of extra life gets breathed into them, and you gain a little more
insight into the mind of Cecil Wilhoit, and dammit, I wish I'd gotten to
meet him, but The Fates decreed otherwise.
First, the Hammerhead Crane had to be removed.
And don't forget, you're standing on a 40-foot square patch of steel deckplate without handrails, over 400 feet up in the air.
Here's the top coming off of the LUT after they had removed the Hammerhead Crane.
And here's what would become the bottom of the FSS.
And they rolled it down the Crawlerway, out to Pad A. Seven years to the day, after they landed on the Moon for the first time.
And you can tell by simply looking that it was one of those brutally-hot July days when they arrived at the Pad.
By September, they were well on the way.
And they just kept right on going, one 40-foot vertical segment at a time...
Welding them one on top of the other, creating the new FSS as they did so.
Immediately above these words, you're seeing Mobile Launcher 2 (which would be used as temporary falsework for the construction of the RSS) sitting beside it astride the Flame Trench at Pad A. The FSS has now risen over 200 feet above the Pad Deck, and there remains only two more Main Levels to go, one carrying the Elevator Machine Room, and the topmost carrying the Hammerhead Crane.
To the right, across the decking of ML-2, directly in front of its still-intact Launch Umbilical Tower, the Rotating Service Structure would take shape and eventually become self-supporting, at which point it would be retracted across the curved Rail Beam you see spanning the Trench, and ML-2 would be taken off of the Pad by the Crawler, and returned to the Park Site north of the VAB.
In this
Pad A image, as all the others showing the erection of the FSS on this page, Wilhoit used a pair of large mobile cranes to erect the segments which made up the growing FSS, but at Pad B, the erection was done with a twin-boom rig very similar to the twin-boom rig you see in the LUT dismantlement images on this page, without benefit of a Mobile Launcher to use as falsework for the RSS, which was instead constructed in its retracted position.
Cecil Wilhoit was extraordinarily savvy, and learned rapidly and deeply as he prosecuted the work, and if he discovered that one of the techniques he was using to do the work might not be fully optimal, he would drop it like a bad habit, turn on a dime, and blaze away at it from there on with a wholly different approach. As I just said, he was extraordinarily savvy.
Return again to Page 35 if you will, for Gene Hajdaj's personal-experience vignette with Cecil, regarding that twin-boom rig which was used to erect the FSS on Pad B.
And I wasn't around for
any of it, and I've managed to live a
long life, a life so
charmed as to
still cause me to wonder...
why, but if I was
forced to choose a
regret, well then, perhaps I'd choose the regret of not having been around when
this stuff went down.
And all of
that just by way of an
introduction, to the
Support Structure for the IAA!
Who knew?
So now we know
exactly where it goes, and
how it got there, maybe let's go give that Support Structure a look on the drawings, and once we're fully understanding of it, we can, at last, return to our
Lift this day, the one we saw getting underway up at the very top of this page in
Image 121.
And when you look at the side of the Support Structure that will be
carrying the IAA, face-on, like you see it here on
79K10338 sheet S-96 Elevation At Column Line 6, you start to get a feel for how
substantial all this stuff is.
And what's all this "
Column Line 6" bullshit, huh?
And we go to a plan view, showing us the IAA Support Structure, and we see that it has its
own set of Column Line designations, just like we've already seen with the OMBUU and a few other things along the way, so here's
79K10338 sheet S-93 looking down at the top of it in plan view, to let you see how that works.
And while you're admiring
that, maybe take note of how the
Lines A and B end of things works, while you're at it.
This is a sterling example of how Column Lines can occasionally go off in funny directions, and just because every Column Line you've ever seen before in your life was square and rectilinear with its
surrounding Column Lines, this is no guarantee in the slightest that the
next Column Line you cross paths with won't suddenly lurch off
at an angle, or maybe some other unexpected weirdness, and if you're not paying attention, yeah, this too can bite you squarely on the ass and wind up costing you
real money because you did the
Bid Takeoff wrong, and
you got the damned job because it was
wrong, and you left a
pile of money
on the table between you and the next-low bidder's bid price, and it turns out there's a
whole lot more going on in there that you failed to ascertain, and yeah, now you're
low bidder and now
you've got to build the fucking thing without going
bankrupt in the process.
Our example above is quite benign, and should cause no
significant trouble if gotten wrong, but in
other places, on
other bids...
...look out!
And I mentioned returning to our Lift, once we have full understanding of the Support Structure, and go back to S-96, which I just referred you to a couple of paragraphs ago, and...
...there's a little
20"GH2 Vent Line (NIC) note hiding in there above the 208'-0" level.
What's that all about?
And back we go again, back down the Rabbit Hole again, and this time we're not looking for any white rabbits, and instead we're looking for
Gaseous Hydrogen.
Oh joy!
The Intertank Access Arm is also known as the Gaseous Hydrogen Vent Arm, and we already know our Space Shuttle is
exceptionally well-endowed with
Hydrogen, and of course they fill up the tank with
Liquid Hydrogen, and jeezus christamongus, I would suppose that
1,450,000 liters of liquid hydrogen should qualify nicely as
well-endowed, and...
"Careful there Lou, this is the same stuff that finished off the
Hindenburg, and we don't wanna be letting
any of it get loose of us while we're playing around with it out here on this Launch Pad, ok?"
And since we're here...
The Hindenburg held 200,000 cubic meters of gaseous hydrogen, and that's a
LOT.
But what happens when we convert that massive 200,000 cubic meters of
gaseous hydrogen into liters of
liquid hydrogen to let us make a fair comparison with what they're using in the Space Shuttle?
We're gonna take every bit of that hydrogen inside the Hindenburg, chill the holy living fuck out of it, all the way down to a completely ridiculous 423 degrees Fahrenheit
below zero, and see how many
liters of the liquid which we find inside of the Space Shuttle's External Tank this will wind up rendering us. (Note: This is
dangerous. Don't try this at home.)
And the calculation spits back a respectably-hefty 236,600 liters of
Liquid Hydrogen, and that's about four standard suburban back-yard swimming pools worth (yes, I know, they're all different, but they all tend to have a pretty standard average size, and I'm going with roughly 60,000 liters), and if your pool is different, well then, fuck you, 'cause I'm
still going with 60,000 liters for a goddamned back-yard swimming pool whether you like it or not.
So.
Take a smidgen less than 4 backyard swimming pools worth of
liquid hydrogen, let it sit until all of it warms up, boils off, and turns into a gas, leaving the pools empty of all liquid, and then take
that, take all that
gaseous hydrogen, and pump it into the goddamned Hindenburg, and Hey Presto! up into the air we go, flying high above the city below in perfect comfort, and... well... it's not going to be
perfect safety, but they thought it was
safe enough... but of course it turned out that they were a little wrong with that part of it, as we all know.
And then you back that Hindenburg's-worth of
liquid hydrogen into the goddamned External Tank, and
that thing holds just a shade less than a
million and a half liters of the stuff...
...and holy shit, that Tank turns out to be worth
SIX HINDENBURGS, and if a thing like
that was to ever go up in flames...
Ye Fucking Gods!
So ok. So we gotta be
real careful with our Liquid Hydrogen when we're out on the Launch Pad, gassing up our Space Shuttle, getting ready to go fly into space, ok?
And the
liquid hydrogen is
constantly boiling off into
gaseous hydrogen, and that hydrogen
gas has way more than enough power to blow the whole place clear to hell, so...
We're gonna need to make good and goddamned sure that a thing like that can
never be allowed to happen...
And to make good and goddamned
sure, they created a whole giant
system to deal with it.
And the hydrogen that
gasses off from the liquid,
inside the External Tank, is, at each and every point along its journey,
contained.
And I guess now we're gonna get to talk about that
containment System for a little while so as we can understand why this thing (including the piece we're gonna be
picking up off the ground and hanging on the side of the tower, if I can ever find a way to shut up about
everything else and get back to the fucking
subject) got built the way they built it.
It's not like they were looking around for holes in the ground to pour millions of dollars into, ok?
They
very definitely had
reasons for building this stuff the way they built it.
And we've brushed up against Hydrogen earlier, when we were learning all about the Centaur Porch and all of the platforming that held it up, back on Page 63, but really, all we did was wave at it as we went by, on our way to hang more iron up in the Steel Forest area of the Struts, between the Hinge Column and the FSS.
And that wasn't
nearly enough, so now it's time to...
...
dig in.
And "The wheels on the bus go round and round, round and round..." No. Wait. Different song. Hang on a minute while I get the right sheet music for this one.
The Hydrogen shows up in
Tanker Trucks, and they drive out to the far northeast area of the Pad, far away from everything else, out by the Perimeter Fence, the better to keep their horrifyingly flammable and explosive cargo away from
things they don't want to destroy if there's an
accident, and...
They pump it, in extraordinarily-cold
liquid form, into the Big Dewar.
Where it sits till they need it...
When they pump it through the cross-country vacuum-jacketed lines up to the pad, through the LH2 Tower, which we met way back on Page 41, and from there into the MLP, and from there, through the Tail Service Mast, and into the Space Shuttle's External Tank...
Where it sits till they need it...
At which point they pump it
furiously into the SSME's, which burn it with Liquid Oxygen, which we also met back on Page 41, and then the SRB's ignite, and up, up, and away, and off we go into the wild black yonder.
But when it's sitting around in the External Tank, and they're waiting for the countdown to get to T-minus
zero, it's constantly boiling off, going from liquid to vapor, and those vapors will keep right on building up inside the Tank, creating higher and higher internal pressures until it
POPS, and of course that wouldn't be very much fun, so they vent the vapors away to keep
that particular unpleasantness from occurring, via the ET Hydrogen Vent System, and that Vent System
contains the explosive
gaseous hydrogen vapors, keeping them from blowing the whole place clear to hell somewhere along the line, and it ducts them far away from the sitting Space Shuttle, most of the way back out to the Big Dewar, where they take a little side-trip to the Burn Pond, but they decided the Burn Pond (which was an Apollo Era thing, and which got used for all the Saturn launches) could stand a little
improvement, so they ditched it in favor of a Flare Stack (and we'll get to see pictures of us installing
that thing, too, later on), which ducted it straight up above the ground, out of everybody's way, where the hydrogen vapors were released into the air and
burned, thereby for once and for all rendering them inert, by combining them with
oxygen in the air, producing
water as a chemical reaction product.
The End.
So let's give it all a bit of a look, shall we?
And now it's time to introduce you to
External Tank GH2 Vent Arm, by Garland E. Reichle, and it's only ten pages, five of which are
pictures, so it's not like you're going to be reading War And Peace, and you really
do need to stop right here and read this thing, all the way through, from the first word until the last, and for the moment, do not trouble yourself over any of the details (or the illustrations) that fail to make proper sense, or even any sense at all.
This one will be the
content pass, and we'll return to it for the
understanding pass, and of course I'm out there a little ahead of you, and I've gone back through for the third pass, which is the
note taking pass, and...
this, by the way, is the
system which my Intro to College Algebra professor introduced to the whole class, as one of the very first things he said, on the very first day of that course, long long ago, back at what used to be called Brevard Community College, but which is now called Eastern Florida State College, and that's exactly what he said, as he stood up in front of everybody holding the goddamned
textbook up in his right hand...
And by this time, I was no longer an
answering machine out at the Pad, and Dick Walls, who I have previously said became as a
second father to me,
forced me at threat of my job, to
go to college because my
name was starting to show up on
paperwork, and certain
entities were beginning to question Sheffield Steel about my
qualifications for putting my goddamned name on what had by then started becoming
very official Space Shuttle Program
paper, thirteen long years after somehow escaping Satellite High School with an actual high school diploma, in a smoke-filled haze back in 1969, and in the intervening years, my (already abysmally-poor) math skills had degraded to a point where, when I did as I was ordered to do and went to BCC and signed up, when I took the entrance assessment tests my math "skills" returned as FOURTH GRADE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL level, and I distinctly recall the terror I felt when taking the math test, and coming to the horrified realization that I couldn't even
divide and multiply fractions, and... I was really, really, REALLY, starting from the
bottom with this one...
...and I'm sitting in a room filled with strangers, and some guy I've never seen before in my entire life is holding a goddamned textbook up in his right hand and going on about...
"If you want to do good in this class, you will read this book
three times. The first time is for content, and you just read the words and look at the symbols and illustrations and you don't worry about what they all mean. Simply read them for
content, and that way you will know what's actually in the book."
"And then you read it a
second time, and this time you're reading it to
understand what's in it, so as you can use that understanding of this subject to allow you to solve the problems and learn how
algebra works."
"And then, after that, you read it a
third time, and on the third reading, you return to those things that you felt like you did not
fully understand, and for those things, you
bear down on it, and as you grapple with each one of them, breaking them down into small enough pieces that you're able to deal with each piece, one at a time, you
make notes in the margins of the book, to tell yourself what each piece really
means, and if you do that, following along with me as I teach this class over the course of this semester while you do so, I can guarantee that you will get an 'A' in my class, and that you will
understand these fundamentals of mathematics which you will need in order to pass all of the other math courses you will be taking, and, more importantly, you will be able to
use mathematics to perform the job or jobs you will be trying to get, and hold, after you have graduated from college."
And from the back of the room came a fairly loud chorus of moans and groans, but for me, sitting front row center (which real estate I was very careful to
grab on the first day of class, for
every class I took), it was like a light had suddenly been turned on, and I took Jim Williams (cannot
believe that name just came back to me as easily as it did) at his word, followed his advice
to the letter, note-taking and all, and...
...I will never know what happened to any of the moaners and groaners sitting there
behind me, but I imagine not all of it was
pleasant, and I, from then on, used this technique in
every class, and in several of those classes, the teachers offered
extra credit questions on exams, and also
graded on a curve, and the hidden nightmare for the moaners and groaners in a system like that is that it's possible, for certain no-fucking-around individuals to
bend the curve backwards, and...
...some of those people very quickly learned to
hate my guts, and of course all
that ever did was to please me mightily, and cause me to redouble my efforts to bend that fucking curve
backwards until things started
breaking, and...
External Tank GH2 Vent Arm is only
ten fucking pages, so read the goddamned thing already!
And for the love of fuck, I've already
shown it to you,
back on Page 66, but I'm guessing that about three of you actually stopped and read the damn thing for
understanding, and now I'm gonna force all of the rest of you to read it for
understanding, because if you
don't then what follows below will be rendered
incomprehensible because of your
lack of understanding, and... fuck you, no apologies, no hall pass, no nothing. Do it or don't, the choice is entirely your own.
So
read it.
And oh yeah, since you've already
seen a couple of the illustrations, in this thing, you're farther along with it than you thought you were, even before you clicked that link and actually started
reading for real.
And now that I think about it, the whole IAA, with all of its associated plumbing and
mechanisms, has never, to my own limited knowledge and experience anyway, been sensible
explicated...
...anywhere.
Sure, there are plenty of sources out there that tell you what it
is, and what it
does, but none of them seem to get into any of the proper
details as regards
how the goddamned thing works.
"It vents gaseous hydrogen from the Space Shuttle's External Tank through an umbilical line that disconnects from the Tank at T-minus 0 which falls away from the Shuttle as it lifts off from the Launch Pad."
Well that's just great.
That one, simultaneously, manages to tell you
everything, even as it also tells you
nothing, and it's always annoyed me, and dammit, I'm gonna see if I can maybe fill in a
few of the details regarding how this thing actually
works, as a part of the whole
system for dealing with the Gaseous Hydrogen that ineluctably
comes off of the Space Shuttle, every time they start messing around with
fueling the goddamned thing.
Wish me luck, ok?
We'll start in the
middle with
79K24048 sheet M-6A, which is the Line Codes Tabulation that includes the GH2 Vent Lines which take the vented Gaseous Hydrogen down from the IAA, toward the Pad Deck, and then across the North Piping Bridge to the LH2 Tower, where it enters the LH2 Trench.
We can see a fragment of it as it takes the turn at the bottom of its run down FSS Side 4, headed out northbound across the ECS Bridge on
79K24048 sheet M-127C. And while we're at it, it would appear as if
my surmise back on Page 66 about going to over/under with the pair of Centaur Lines having to be done because of "there's a lot of crap running up Side 4 of the FSS" turns out to be true, because on M-127C you can see the Centaur Lines moving out of the way of that existing GH2 Vent Line, sitting right on the
centerline of the FSS on Side 4, and yeah... "a lot of crap" which leads directly to "did not have enough room."
And I went ahead and returned to
Image 101, gave it a close look, found the GH2 Vent Line, and marked it up so you can see it. We don't have
any good images of this thing, so we're kind of stuck with the crummy ones we've got, and if they ever invent
time travel, one of the first things I'm going to do is return to the Pad, back when we were still building it, and instruct 1980's MacLaren to take
better pictures goddamnit.
More fragments of it can be seen beneath the Centaur Piping new installation on
79K24048 sheet M-127B, at the corner where it departs the ECS Bridge for the North Piping Bridge above the LOX Tower, and again on the other side of the Flame Trench at the east end of the North Piping Bridge.
From there, the GH2 Vent Line heads out across the same run of pipe supports that carry the
Liquid Hydrogen VJ Lines from the Big Dewar to the Pad Body, but it doesn't make it all the way, and out there in the middle of the run, it takes a detour across to the Burn Pond, which I've already mentioned is a holdover from Apollo Days, and which was replaced by the Flare Stack before anybody flew any Shuttles from Pad B.
We'll use
79K24048 sheet M-19, LH2 MPS Key Plan, to see where this ET Gaseous Hydrogen Vent Line stuff goes after it comes off of the Pad Deck, although it's certainly not the correct drawing to be using for what we're doing here. If I had the correct drawing, I'd use it, but, as with so much else in this narrative, I have had to cobble things together using whatever's laying around available to me because NASA Public Affairs categorically refuses to furnish the
least mote of Good Information, and has become
completely ossified all these years after they were once such a
sterling Public Outreach organization, diligently working as hard as they could, to share the
wonders of the Space Program with the general public, in a very rewarding effort to stimulate public interest in
STEM fields, which in turn rewarded the country as a whole
right back, because of all the bright-eyed children and
adults who got to
see this stuff, and determined that they just might be able to
do this stuff, and proceeded with their educations and lives accordingly, and...
...oh well.
But now we're finally getting into some
interesting territory, and
M-19 is showing us the
Burn Pond, but I've marked it to let you know that the Burn Pond was replaced by the Flare Stack, and never got used for any Shuttle flights, but it's a
deeply fascinating object, and it pops up all over the place when you start looking around for stuff telling you about Pad A or Pad B, and it was an
integral part of the systems that successfully got all of those Saturns up off the ground, and nobody seems to have anything about it...
anywhere, and of course that pisses me off, so ok, so I'm gonna take this detour from our detour to take
another detour, and...
HYDROGEN. (And if you have any sense at all, you would have
known this was coming.)
And Hydrogen is...
radical. (Isn't
everything out here? Of course it is. That's why we
like the place so much. It don't get no more radical than heavy-lift
Launch Pads. So let's keep right on
digging in.)
And we're out here at the world's largest Liquid Hydrogen storage and
transport facility, and...
...Here's the plan: "Don't fuck up."
Simple enough plan, I guess, but with
Hydrogen...
Hydrogen really, really,
really wants you to fuck up. And it wants to fuck
you up, too.
Big time.
Let's get a little background on it, how 'bout?
We'll start out small, with a document that only runs 5 pages, and about half of that page real estate is taken up by pictures, so it's a pretty easy read, and it goes by the ever-so-cheerful name of "
EXPLOSIVE LESSONS IN HYDROGEN SAFETY" and it was written by Russel Rhodes, who was pretty much there from the
beginning, out on the Cape, and it does a pretty good job of alerting you to the
deviousness of systems that are tasked with transporting large quantities of Liquid Hydrogen through plumbing runs that are long enough to keep the stored mass of the stuff far enough away from where it's getting used, to, hopefully, prevent
everything from being destroyed should a little oopsie perchance happen somewhere along the line.
So now that you're
aware, maybe you're ready for
Hydrogen Incident Examples, and it's only 41 pages, so again, not such a long read, and in this one we learn that people are mucking about with Hydrogen
all over the place and not just with Big Rockets, and we also learn that Hydrogen apparently has
eyes and it's
looking for you.
Next, we'll broaden our horizons on the Space Center a little, and include other flavors of
cryo, but don't think they gave Hydrogen short shrift in
CRYOGENIC TRANSFER SYSTEM MECHANICAL DESIGN HANDBOOK KSC-DM-3557, by Frank S. Howard, Special Projects Branch, DM-MED-1, NASA, KSC, Florida, because
it's there, and not only is it
there, Frank also gives us our very best look at the actual
guts of the Burn Pond, the
Bubble Cap Vent Pipes (which are a seriously
clever solution to a very knotty and unforgiving problem, and which he introduces to us at the bottom of Page 14) and before we go any further (you have been presumed to have
read this thing), we're gonna stop and look at a couple of drawings of the Burn Pond, and maybe when you're done, you'll be able to look at Pad Stuff in the future, and be one of the
very few who actually understand the
sense of the thing, and why they had to build it and use it, without which.. the whole place may very well have gone up in flames and that would have been the end of that, right? Frank also introduces us to the
Vaporizer weirdness that you'll be seeing on the drawings I'm about to show you too, and prior to reading his very well-done document, I had no idea what any of
that stuff was for, either. And of course, along the way, he gives us more than enough examples of how
things can go wrong, in occasionally
spectacular fashion. So... way to go, Frank! Yaaaaaaay!
But before we go look at the promised drawings of the damn thing, we can't just whistle our merry way past
REPORT NO. RP-TIVI-0007 to SPACE NUCLEAR PROPULSION OFFICE - CLEVELAND EXTENSION, PHOEBUS-2, HYDROGEN DISPOSAL BURN POND, without stopping to give it the time and attention which it is so manifestly worthy of, and if you
ever wanted to learn how Hydrogen Burn Ponds work, well then, this is the document for you. It's got pictures and everything. Runs a little long, to 95 pages, but it's nothing
you can't handle, right?
So. Burn Pond.
So. Here's
sheet S-202 from the original Apollo Pad B Structural drawings, showing the overall LH2,
RP1 (highly refined and purified
kerosene), and GH2 Pipe Supports general arrangement layout and dimensions in plan view for this quadrant of the Pad, which I've yellow-highlighted to help you identify the salient features it's showing, and to also let you see the actual
dimensions of this stuff, and as you can plainly see, it covers some respectable
acreage, and they put that Burn Pond more or less right in the
middle of that run of LH2 Piping, midway between the Saturn V and the LH2 Storage Dewar, in an effort to keep the goddamned thing as far from
everything else as they could, and of course
these are among the numbers that drove the original
size and
outline of the Pad, as it was first designed and
built, so it's kinda nice to have 'em, right?
And then we go to
Apollo sheet S-205 to see the Burn Pond itself, and it's pretty brain-dead without the plumbing (which itself is none too complicated, although I'd love to show it to you, but all of this Hydrogen
mechanical stuff was handled
elsewhere, and I possess none of those
original drawings, although I diligently
continue to keep
looking for them), being just a hundred foot by ninety foot by three feet deep
kiddie pool kind of thing (that you could put a
lot of kiddies into, all frolicking about in the water under the watchful eyes of... maybe even Wernher von Braun himself, who knows?), but despite it's bare-bones simplicity, it would have been a wonder to behold, to actually watch this bitch
in action (making double-damn good and sure that
every last one of those
kiddies had been properly and fully
accounted for and gotten the hell
out of it and far far
away from it, first) with the water in a state of agitation as the
three hundred degrees below zero Fahrenheit hydrogen gas was coming out of all the Bubble Cap Vent Pipes from just beneath its surface, and turning into an invisible full-coverage blanketing inferno of 4,000 degrees
above zero Fahrenheit see-through-clear hydrogen
flames all across the full area of the Pond. I can only imagine the uncanny and not-quite-right
sound it made, and pity the poor birds and bugs that did not recognize or understand what the heat-wavy
look of more distant objects seen through those clear flames really
meant, blithely flying into the unseeable edge of that wall of flame, and... alas, I wasn't invited to
that party, so I cannot tell you how fucking
cool that thing was, when they were
running it. But I'm pretty sure it was
really cool.
But I would also be extraordinarily
leery about ever approaching the sonofabitch because... wouldn't it be a shame if something
untoward was to
occur while in the near vicinity of it, and yeah, they're pretty well organized out here, and the odds of a thing like that actually
happening are vanishingly low, but to be there at the edge of this motherfucker idly splishing your hand in the water while bemusedly considering how to smuggle a few goldfish into the thing just for laughs, and all of a sudden... fffsssSS
SHHHOOORRRRFFFFFFFF!!!
And a thing like that could go from pleasant to
unpleasant pretty damn quick, and...
Of course they were all made to read
SAFETY STANDARD FOR HYDROGEN AND HYDROGEN SYSTEMS... but still...
I'd still be mighty mighty
mighty leery of ever getting any kind of
close to that thing, anyway.
And since we're already in the area, sort of, farting around with all this stuff, here's
79K24048 sheet M-20 to let you see what that big LH2 Dewar is sitting more or less directly above, including the weirdly-outsize Vaporizers (there's
two of 'em, and that redundancy with this thing should be telling you just how
critical it was to the operation of the system when it came to actually
moving the Liquid Hydrogen from the Dewar to the Pad), and you are presumed to have already read it, but here's a link to
Page 8 of CRYOGENIC TRANSFER SYSTEM MECHANICAL DESIGN HANDBOOK KSC-DM-3557, where Frank tells us what the deal is with the Vaporizer, for all you slacker fucktards who failed to read this document earlier, despite having been
told to do so, for good and sufficient reasons.
Ok.
That should be enough of that.
And now we know what the
back end of this stuff looks and acts like, maybe we can return to the
front end, and figure out what the fuck is going on with all that ridiculously-contrapted rigamaroo with the Intertank Access Arm, which, in case you have forgotten, is the whole
point of this particular page of the narrative, it having been kicked off with
the first in a series of photographs of Ivey Steel's Union Ironworkers hanging that monstrosity on the Fixed Service Structure at Pad B.
We departed the scene of that particular crime while still considering the Support Structure on the north side of the FSS, that holds up the IAA, just after discovering some sort of
20" GH2 Vent Line (NIC) on 79K10338 sheet S-96, which took us all the way back to Wilhoit Days on the Pad, before I showed up as Sheffield's brand new
answering machine.
And then we
jumped away, working in
reverse, from the middle, to the
back end, winding up all the way out to
the Big LH2 Dewar, far from the scene of our original crime, in what turned out to be a
very necessary effort to gain enough proper
understanding of the extraordinarily-violent
potentialities and extraordinarily-devious
complexities inherent with using
Liquid Hydrogen as
fuel, to let us then move
forward with further understanding of exactly why and how they
vent the stuff in gaseous form away from our Launch Vehicle...
safely.
But now we're gonna need to turn back around and start working from the middle to the front end, where the GH2 Umbilical Carrier Plate is in direct contact with the External Tank, and in so doing, lean in to things a little
harder, and get for once and for all to the bottom of the matter, as it relates to keeping the Shuttle from blowing itself up while still sitting on the Pad,
mid-twang, ramping the SSME's up to full power, prior to SRB Ignition and Liftoff.
You now know
exactly what it is, so here's our GH2 Vent Line running across both the IAA and its Support Structure, headed toward its final destiny with a Carrier Plate that's flush up against the External Tank, and you see it shown in plan view on
79K24048 sheet M-343, and this was originally a worksheet, which I needed to create in order to
work my way through the Hall of Mirrors that is 79K24048, keeping in mind that
many of those mirrors in that hall are cracked, and missing pieces, or completely not there at all, or, most alarmingly, are
distorting funhouse mirrors, and... we certainly
do wish we had the
correct set of drawings for all of this thing, but...
...we do not...
...and I decided to just go ahead and
use the damn thing right here in this narrative, and I'm just gonna
dump the damn thing on you without any up-front explanation of it...
...and then I'll attempt to walk you through it as best I can later on as we continue on our Journey of Wonder, Through The Land of Hydrogen...
...but this fucking thing is
COMPLICATED...
Which is probably why nobody else has ever taken a run at properly
explaining it to anybody beyond their own narrowly-defined home world of technicians, engineers, and program managers.
And I flagged a couple of small G (can't be
Liquid, because they have no proper insulation or vacuum jacketing) H2 lines, pressurized to 3,000 psi, on M-343, and you're like... what's the issue here? And you
lose sight of where you
really are, and just how horrifyingly
dangerous the place is and...
Ok, it's wet dress-rehearsal day, and we need to
fill the Tank to proof the system, but we're not gonna actually
burn all that Liquid Hydrogen
fuel we filled that goddamned tank up with, and instead we're gonna
drain the Tank...
So ok, so
drain the fucked-up Tank and be done with it, and shut up about it already.
But wait...
What's going to fill the gigantic
void now occupying the Tank?
We gotta fill it up with
something, or it might
collapse, or perhaps just
bend a little somewhere, or maybe place an unacceptable
strain on something that was never designed to see any such strain (
everything has been pared down to the
bone, in a crazed effort to keep the whole shebang
light enough to even reach orbit in the first place), or maybe it'll just want to get all pissy about giving us our Hydrogen back, and try to hold on to it via vacuum suction, and that leads to its own set of
troubles which we very very much want nothing to do with...
And we can't just turn the valves and let what's in the
Vent Line back into the Tank, 'cause that stuff was a
severe fire and explosion hazard for every second of its existence, and you
never let a Hydrogen
Vent Line suck any
air back in when the pressure drops, and those valves are
closed, and they're going to
stay closed..
So
air getting together in any way shape or form with Gaseous Hydrogen, no matter where it came from, is
strictly forbidden, so... ok, how 'bout we use some of the
Nitrogen we've got all over the place that we use (among other things) as a non-flammable
purge gas?
Nope.
Hard no, on that one, too.
Nitrogen will
liquefy at minus 321 Fahrenheit, which is almost exactly
one hundred degrees warmer than the Liquid
Hydrogen we're fucking around with here, and if the stuff that we're trying to use to fill a void left by the departure of our Liquid Hydrogen decides to
liquefy, itself, well... there goes your gas pressure, and we're right back where we started, and that's not good, and bring it down another 25 degrees Fahrenheit, and the goddamned stuff
freezes solid, and the thought of blocks of frozen Nitrogen getting into the innermost nooks and crannies of our Hydrogen System, while we're moving Hydrogen around in it, is a deeply frightening one, and perchance you used it
anyway, maybe even on
Launch Day... well... it would freeze on contact with the surface of the Liquid Hydrogen in the Tank, and that
frozen Nitrogen would
promptly sink to the bottom, down to where the inlets for hungry turbopumps are looking for a drink, and start
accumulating, and those turbopumps will drink Nitrogen
rocks just as quick as they'll drink a refreshing beverage of Liquid Hydrogen, and presuming the Nitrogen rocks did not simply plug up the inlet and block the flow of liquid, causing the turbopumps to cavitate (yet
another surefire way to blow the whole place sky high), when the Nitrogen rocks (or even just small pieces of Nitrogen
gravel, or even Nitrogen
sand) pass through the inlet into the plumbing and eventually make it to the ferociously-high-speed spinning turbine blades in there, the blades and the bearings might not like that all so very much... and... NO.
Hard no on Nitrogen.
We
can use Helium, and in certain circumstances they
do, but Helium too, comes with its own set of technical and financial
problems, and it turns out, in a
lot of cases, you wind up needing...
Gaseous Hydrogen to keep things both ventish and supplyish from
sucking air and blowing the whole place to hell, and of course when you're doing
that you're gonna need to be...
venting your GH2
Purge Gas, and that ties you right back to your system for getting the damn stuff well and truly the hell
out of here, in a
fully contained way, all the way back to your Burn Pond or Flair Stack, and once you start actually
building this stuff...
Plumber's Nightmare does not even
begin to describe what you wind up with, trying to keep from sending the whole place up like a Russian oil refinery that the Ukrainians decided they didn't like having around anymore.
And we recently learned in CRYOGENIC TRANSFER SYSTEM MECHANICAL DESIGN HANDBOOK KSC-DM-3557 how they use
pressure (which is
why the Vaporizers) instead of
pumps to
push the Hydrogen around in the system, and that little nugget of information might go a long way toward explaining the little "HYDR RETURN (3000 PSI)" and "HYDR SUPPLY (3000 PSI)" notes flagging a couple of quite small (¾" and ½") lines, in the upper left-hand area of M-343, because otherwise... whuffo three
thousand pounds of pressure per square inch in a system that's only supposed to be
venting some excess Gaseous Hydrogen out of our External Tank whenever we're fucking around with
fueling operations out here on the Pad?
And I am most manifestly
not qualified to talk about
any of these (and no end of
other) complexities and considerations, so you get to look at some of these drawings, and...
Fuck all if I know what that shit's there for, or what it's doing, or why they were (without the slightest doubt)
forced into doing it that way.
Can't help ya.
Maybe try the next office down the hall.
Good luck and godspeed.
So now we return to
79K24048 sheet M-343, and this time we're looking at the existing FSS and IAA Support Structure in pink, and the part of the IAA that we're lifting today in blue, and you can flip back up-page to Image 121 if you'd like to compare it with what this plan view is showing, and you can verify for yourself that the
Swing Arm part of things is very definitely
not part of the IAA
structure that we lifted, and that damn Swing Arm turns out to be just about a
confusing motherfucker when it comes to
understanding this thing, so...
Oh boy, here we go, Swing Arm City.
And when it comes to imagery of Space Shuttles lifting off, this whole side of things is quite-poorly represented in what you generally
see, and that's because it's kind of stuffed in there between the tower and the bird, and for the most part, everything you get visually is looking from the other direction, from somewhere east or south of things.
And "East" makes perfect sense, because the FSS and the RSS are not blocking the view, but "South" is a little less obvious, and you get that end of things because that's the side of the Stack that the Orbiter is on, and
everybody wants to see the Orbiter, and
nobody wants to see the stupid External Tank blocking it from view, and...
For the most part, our present area of interest is poorly-represented, and you never get to see what's going over there on the northwest side of the Stack with the IAA
at Liftoff.
But there
is stuff out there (NASA, if nothing else, is pretty damn good at getting
lots of videos of their Spaceship taking off from every imaginable angle), and the reason nobody ever sees any of it is because the fucked-up
Media invariably chooses those views that best show the Orbiter as it's coming up off the Pad, and of course the IAA is nowhere to be seen from those Media-favored viewing angles.
Yet another reason to globally fear and mistrust the goddamned
Media, all of it,
everybody's, even
mine, as a blanket policy
ab initio. Media
bias comes in a million different guises, pollutes and distorts our thinking in a million different ways, and a
lot of it consists in
blind spots that are created because the goddamned Media demands the absolute maximum Wow Factor, and an awful lot of the world around us simply
fails to show up because of this, and some of it's pretty fucking
important, but people think they know what's going on anyway, because blind spots... are pretty fucking
hard to see, eh?
And I've grabbed a pretty good vid from NASA that shows what we're looking for, and we're gonna see it here soon enough, but first, a little more background on the stupid Swing Arm, ok?
And for that, best we'd start out by asking ourselves, "What's that fucking Swing Arm even
for, anyway?"
And the answer to
that turns out to be one of those things that lives in one of those
blind spots I was just warning you about, and...
So ok, what
is it?
And what it is, is the
means by which we can attach the actual
Vent Line to the side of the External Tank, so as we don't immolate ourselves in an
Oxyhydrogen Inferno, and the actual
Vent Line, the actual
thing that
attaches to the Tank, is a laughably-minor-looking piece of the overall IAA
System.
Complicating the issue, our previously-referenced Media-induced dearth of information prevents most people from even having an
awareness that the Swing Arm and the Vent Line are actually
two very separate and distinct things, completely independent of each other, moving in completely different ways and directions, at completely separate times, in response to completely separate needs and
events.
Onward.
They
knew they were gonna have to deal with this bullshit, the instant they
settled on a design for their Space Shuttle that involved the use of Hydrogen for Fuel...
But in the
very beginning, in
earliest Shuttle Ur-time, back at the very
top of the
Design Cascade I told you about waaaay back on Page 6...
...nobody knew
nuthin.
Size? Shape? Weight? Payload? Booster? Cost? Look? Smell? Feel?
Who the fuck knows?
Was it gonna be small enough to just sit it down on top of a existing military rocket that had already been designed, built, tested, and proven?
Maybe. Maybe not.
Was it gonna be fucking GIANT and lift off of the pad carried by some damned Winged Monster or other that would return to the Launch Site on its own, making the entire system totally and completely reusable? Maybe. Maybe not.
Was it gonna be straight-wing or delta-wing? Nobody knew.
Was it gonna be the most stupidest-looking thing you've ever seen in your life? Let's hope not.
Was it gonna look like a cross between an XB-70 and a stuffed turkey? Well... that might be better than
Chrysler's idea.
Was it gonna reuse very-slightly-modified Apollo flight hardware? Maybe. Maybe not.
Was it going to use very-slightly-modified Apollo ground hardware? Maybe. Maybe not.
Was there simply no end of daffy design concepts and proposals floating all around out there like deranged snowflakes in a brain-damaged blizzard? You bet your ass there was!
And at the close of this Paleoarchean era, time, money, and political expediency had forced them into the corner they wound up in, complete with the use of Hydrogen as fuel, and a, sort of, sense for what the Pad GSE (
Ground
Support
Equipment) was gonna look like, but even then, when it came to venting the goddamned Hydrogen away from this stuff, there were
still... many questions.
And what about the Pad? What the hell are we gonna do about
that?
And I
told you to
read it, farther up on this page, and yet here I am,
holding you by the goddamned hand, showing you image by image, some of the possibilities that
might have eventuated with what became the IAA, as the slush ice of the
design was still congealing into the solid block which wound up going into
production.
And they got it reduced down to
three "finalists", and as engineers are wont to do, they very creatively named them "Concept 1", "Concept 2", and "Concept 3."
And
Concept 1 got rejected first, because it introduced a
weight penalty in the form of additional
plumbing that they could not bear, because it ate far too deeply into their
performance numbers, taking away too much
Payload capacity (which, of course, in a "real" world, is the whole point of the operation, but the Space Shuttle,
from the very outset, dwelt in a world that was only
part real, and the other part was
political, but either way, the additional plumbing required for Concept 1 wound up being too heavy, so... nope).
Concept 2 got the axe next, after they realized that it would involve a
lot of time and expense, modifying the MLP, in addition to the most very unpleasant fact that the Shuttle just might
HIT the damn thing, coming up off the MLP, and of course that would be kinda bad too, right?
Which left them
stuck with
Concept 3, which was
very sub-optimal, but they
had to use it, and it was not a Happy Thing, but it's what they wound up with, anyway, and as with every other goddamned
drawing of this thing that I've ever found, our drawing is near-useless for understanding (what is, admittedly, a subtly-complicated thing, none too easy to explain in a single image), so
I've marked up the Concept 3 drawing to, hopefully, let you see what's going on with it.
And now at last I get to introduce you to
The Elephant's Trunk, which is the innermost heart and
guts of the whole system.
And out on the Pad, everybody, and I do mean
everybody, always referred to that final portion of the GH2 Vent Line which consisted of both flexible and hard line-segments, and which simply
fell away from the Shuttle at the moment of Liftoff...
...as
The Elephant's Trunk.
Ev-re-body.
All-ways.
Elephant's Trunk.
So get used to it, 'cause
that's what it is.
And
here it is, in action, in the video I promised you I'd show you, a little while ago. That's it, a little left and below center. Thinnish white (which is a solid coating of
ice, which is telling us that the GH2 it's carrying away from the Tank is fucking
COLD) line looking thing at about a forty-five degree angle to the External Tank, which it's attached to on the left side. And around 19 seconds in, when we start getting some
real action, but before Liftoff, it begins to shiver violently (you can't see it in the vid, but it's definitely
happening), shedding its coating of ice, which falls away as a cloud of large and small pieces of debris. And just about 26 seconds into this video (which is
really excellent), following the whole Stack bending left an alarming amount for a gigantic thing that everybody expects to be as rigid as
building, but it's
not, and then bending
back, the whole line just... drops. Drops
straight down. As the Shuttle starts moving
straight up and also moving
toward it, and you better believe that goddamned thing has
got to be out of the way in time, or otherwise...
bad juju. Very bad juju, just as soon as the Space Shuttle starts rising.
And when I just told you this whole system was
sub-optimal, perhaps now you can start to get a better idea of why I might say a thing like that.
It worked. Let the record show that it
worked. Every single time. It never
hurt anybody.
And
here's another video, that focuses primarily on the Carrier Plate, but is also simple enough and generally-informative enough that I figure it might be worth including, in an effort to increase your understanding of the overall system.
But every single time the Space Shuttle lifted off, you can
assure yourself that there were certain people, in certain places, whose hearts were in their throats, until the goddamned thing got far enough up into the air
to leave this motherfucker behind.
Every. Single. Launch.
No exceptions.
The Elephant's Trunk was one of the very most
frightening elements in the whole place.
And you look at it with Eyes That Do Not See, and you think nothing of it. And really, you think not at all.
But other eyes were having other thoughts every single time.
And for some reason, in every operational drawing of this thing, you
always get the Swing Arm part of it in its extended position, with the Elephant's Trunk showing up as some sort of ill-defined
integral part of the swing arm.
But the Elephant's Trunk was no such thing.
And you just
never get to see it sitting out there in it's
work position without that goddamned Swing Arm in there, mucking it all up, and blocking proper understanding of this stuff.
And when it's done
wrong, like it's done here on
79K24048 sheet M-338, it's near-impossible to understand.
But if some kind soul comes along and
fixes the goddamned thing, giving you a second view with that miserable
Arm properly retracted, and out of the way, then all of a sudden that altered
79K24048 sheet M-338 with the Swing Arm retracted suddenly starts to make one
hell of a lot more sense, and...
...you're welcome.
And it turns out we can actually
see this thing, sort of, not really
all too well, but...
well enough, on our photograph at the top of the page,
Image 121.
Although our old friend, Structural Steel, doesn't really
want us to.
So I had to work that image a little bit, to let you see the item in question, and to give you a bit of information as to what it is that's visible there as part of the IAA we're lifting.
And here's a copy of
Image 121, with the GH2 Hydrogen Vent lines all nice and labeled up for you.
And now we're starting to learn how this thing actually
works, and, although it does not
look like it, it works an awful lot like any of the other T-Zero umbilicals you've already crossed paths with in no end of included links to reference documents, and at least one vid, in this thing, and what happens is that they
snatch it a short distance away from contact with the Vehicle, which allows them to then immediately
swing it a farther distance away without catastrophically
grinding, gouging, or tearing it across the side of a Launch Vehicle which may be
drifting in their direction as it sways and shudders and shimmies and shakes upward into the sky while they're doing so, and the only real difference with this thing, as opposed to the Swing Arms for a Saturn V, is that instead of getting swung across
to the side, Arm and all, this thing is simply allowed to
fall and the "Arm" part of things never enters into that part of the equation.
So it's the same, but it's
different, too.
Explosive bolts on the Umbilical Carrier Plate at the far end of the Vent Line blow, detaching it from the External Tank, and the Vent Line along with the Carrier Plate that's still firmly attached to it,
immediately gets jerked two feet straight back and away from the now-moving Shuttle by the pivoting Pivot Arm which has been under some pretty good tension the whole time because of a dropweight with a line reeved over a pulley, applying sidewise pulling force on it from inside the IAA.
If the explosive bolts fail to blow (never happened, but they for sure as hell weren't taking
any chances with this thing), the Shuttle would rise up far enough that the Secondary Release System would kick into gear, and
snatch the Carrier Plate off of the External Tank via the use of a Lanyard that was connected to the Carrier Plate on one end, and the lower front end of the IAA on its other end. And if the bolts didn't blow, the Shuttle would keep rising, and the Lanyard would suddenly came
taut, and the moving end of the Lanyard would stop cold, then and there, like all good wire ropes do when you've pulled them until there's no more slack to take up.
This of course keeps the Carrier Plate from being pulled any farther
upward by the Space Shuttle it was
still attached to, and more or less rips it off the side of the Tank, which of course kept right on going up into the sky following Liftoff.
And yes, the system was designed with this in mind, and the valves would snap shut either way, and it's not like there'd be some kind of
hole opened up in the side of the External Tank if this thing was ever invoked, and yes, just as soon as the Carrier Plate gets torn off the side of the Tank and becomes disconnected from it, the Pivot Arm immediately does its thing because of the falling dropweight, snatching it two feet sideways away from the tank, just as soon as the disconnection occurs.
So the Pivot Arm snatches the Vent Line sideways no matter
what happens. Immediately. Once that Carrier Plate releases its hold on the Tank
and the dropweight suddenly becomes free to
fall.
And it's that "Pivot Arm" linkage kind of deal, up there in the top corner of the Blast Shield, the thing that wants to initially pull the Vent Line 2 feet straight back away from the Tank at the instant the explosive bolts fire, that seems to be the source of everybody's confusion, or utter ignorance.
And the Pivot Arm works exactly like any other linkage arm you've ever encountered in your life (and linkage arms are as common as dirt, and can be found
everywhere). It's hinged up on its
top end, and
it has a lanyard of its own hooked to it, internal to the IAA, using the dropweight I mentioned, to yank the lower end of it back away from the Tank along with the Vent Line which is firmly attached to it, down at the bottom end of the Arm. The bottom end of the Pivot Arm doesn't get yanked very far, (it's only two feet, right?) but it's
far enough, and as that happens, the Vent Line which is now completely disconnected from the Tank, suspended solely by its hinged connection to the bottom of the Pivot Arm... falls down. Straight down, swinging on its hinge which is attached to the
retracted lower end of the Pivot Arm, down and away from the rising Space Shuttle as it does so.
And when you think about it, that's actually pretty cool, and it gets the work done with a
lot less hardware to do it, and up up and away we go, unencumbered by any (still-attached, torn-from-the-tower and dangling, and already maneuvering to
kill us all in the next few seconds) GH2 Vent Line
apparatus as we do so.
So it's weird-looking, and it's a little hard to
understand, but it's actually a pretty slick system they cooked up for this stuff.
But certain people, in certain places, worried
deeply about it anyway,
every single time.
And it turns out that despite the simplicity of the concept, letting the Vent Line simply
fall, there turns out to be a
lot of complicating factors, and some of them are pretty non-obvious.
It's not the kind of thing that jumps out at you and causes you to
consider it, when you're considering the whole business of a
falling Vent Line, but the damn thing has got to go
somewhere, and that
somewhere needs to
accommodate the damn thing in some way, instead of just being some kind of
empty space where it can dangle freely, after falling. It needs a
Latchback,
and we learned all about Latchbacks with the GOX Arm, but of course this one is going to be
significantly different, and they're not even calling it a "Latchback" anymore and instead it has become an "Umbilical Retention Mechanism" and sometimes they call it the "Deceleration Unit" and of course, when you're actually
reading the
documents you discover that sometimes they use
Metric, and sometimes they use
US Customary Units, and isn't
that just too much fun?
And on top of
that, when they
revisited this stuff (which they're always doing, looking for oversights and hidden flaws in their original lines of reasoning and understanding of the systems they're
implementing, in a never-ending effort to keep from... falling afoul of Bad Things), they discovered that there were certain
scenarios in which... Bad Things could happen in the few seconds it took for the Vent Line to
fall. This thing is
scary, and everybody on the
inside knew it was scary, and none of them were inclined to turn their backs on it, in any way.
And they found
issues with the Secondary Release System Lanyard, which is the wire rope attached to the Vent Line Assembly, out at the Umbilical Carrier Plate, which was there for
just in case, and which it turned it out was
never invoked, not even once, but that didn't keep them from wanting to make damn good and sure that... just in case... this thing couldn't decide to unexpectedly
turn on them.
So ok, here we go
again with this stuff. Sigh.
And In The Beginning, they originally decided that it would be enough to let the far end of the Vent Line where the Structural Support for the Forward Flex line is located, fall into the
Deceleration Unit, which is a surprisingly-contrapted thing that lives on the front of the IAA, down at the bottom, and let the Lanyard just sort of flop down with it, and wind up wherever it wound up.
And events conspired to cause them to
revisit this stuff about how the Lanyard works, as regards what happens immediately after Liftoff, and as regards what happens after the Vent Line has fallen all the way down into the Deceleration Unit where the Structural Support for the Forward Flex Line enters the Decel Unit and bangs into that wire in there. Here's a closer look at that Structural Support for the Forward Flex Line (it's too small, but it's all we've got) in this
marked-up copy of 79K24048 sheet M-345, labeled in green, along with all of the other main players that can be found out at the terminal end of the GH2 Vent Line where it meets the External Tank.
So they came up with a couple of modifications, and you can read all about it here in
Modification and Development of the External Tank Hydrogen Vent Umbilical System for the Space Shuttle, by our old friend Bemis C. Tatem Jr., whose work we've seen before, twice even, once with the PGHM back on Page 36, and then again more recently with some of the Centaur Rolling Beam stuff on page 63. So I guess Bemis is a pretty well qualified person to be using as a source for this stuff, too.
And then, after that,
more problems cropped up, and with the launch of STS-108, the goddamned Vent Line failed to even
enter the Decel Unit, and instead, it smashed violently into the IAA Structure surrounding it, and
pieces flew, and had some of those
pieces flown into the rising Orbiter, or External Tank... that could have
ended things, then and there, and...
The Decel Unit was modified, along with other recommended actions, and despite the deeply-frightening
reason for the creation of this document,
Gaseous Hydrogen (GH2) Vent Arm Behavior Prediction Model Review Technical Assessment Report (which is the source document for our drawing of the Decel Unit) is an
excellent piece of work because it contains graphics that let us see the mechanical workings of this stuff in a clear and understandable manner, and I recommend you give it a look, 'cause there's some pretty cool stuff in there.
Nobody ever actually
liked anything about this whole IAA ET Gaseous Hydrogen Vent thing, and I never heard so much as a
single kind word about it the whole time I was having to deal with it out on the Pad, and in addition to everything else, some people worried that the Orbiter's Left Wing might HIT the goddamned thing on its way up off the MLP, and everybody feared and mistrusted it deeply, and... those who
knew had way more than enough
good reasons for their fear and mistrust, and...
And
that has got to be just about enough of
that shit, and you are now presumed to
understand this thing, and can we
please get back to the fucking IAA Lift? Pretty Please? With cream and sugar on top?
And here we are, and we're on our way
up.
With
a hundred thousand pounds of steel.
This was our heaviest Lift during this phase of work, but the basics of the Lift were no different from any of what you've already seen with the GOX Arm and the OMBUU, and you are presumed to have a feel for those basics by now.
We're standing on the east side of the Flame Trench, a little bit past the
MLP Orbiter Exhaust Holes SSW Riser (which you can see, labeled, in
Image 045, which was taken from very nearly the same location)
looking across at the now-suspended IAA. The transporter which carried it up to the Pad Deck is gone, and a pair of Union Ironworkers are on top of the MLP Utilities Interface Platform at elevation 68'-4" with their outstreched arms barely giving them hands-on purchase upon the bright-red Firex line which runs along the perimeter of the IAA just below the lowest grating level, at its bottom-left corner. To the left of them, a third ironworker stands on top of the Utilities Interface Platform at the ready, but things are going well, and all three of them will be hitting that stair pretty quick, returning to the Pad Deck, and from there heading over to the base of the FSS, to enter the elevator for a ride upwards to greet the IAA when it arrives, most likely at either the 200'-0" level or the 220'-0" level, both of which locations are where the
connection is going to be made.
Working a hundred thousand pounds of steel in free suspension, keeping it aligned properly, from their arms-full-extended position you're seeing in the photograph, is a losing proposition, which gives me to believe that I hit the shutter release for this image shortly after the Intertank Access Arm had begun its final vertical motion, straight up toward its destination, the merest split-second before it floated completely out of our ironworkers' reach. From then on, it was solely under the control of another, unseen, ironworker at the bottom of the tag line, which you can see attached to the IAA on its bottom right corner, draping down and across the 9099 Building until it goes out of frame, a little above the bottom right corner of the photograph.
In the near foreground, backs to the camera, that
might be a pair of TT&V operatives. We're not too far from Howard Baxter's TT&V trailer. But then again, maybe they're not. Might be NASA. Might be damn near anybody. Except craft labor. These people are dressed all wrong to be craft labor, from shoes to hardhats, and the windbreakers are telling us it was cool this day, but not
cold. Wintertime shadows, from a lower-angle late-morning sun, agree with that assessment. Interested parties for operations like this one come in no end of differing sizes, shapes, and agencies, and I have no idea as to the proper identities of either one of these individuals.
Between them, across the Flame Trench, someone else whose name I cannot give you stands, but I
can tell you he's an
ironworker. Everybody else, not
directly involved with the Lift, has by now been shooed away, and until the IAA is firmly bolted to the tower, the ironworkers are in sole and exclusive possession of things.
The IAA has been rotated around to the orientation it will have after it's been bolted to the tower, and we're looking at the Elephant's Trunk nearly face-on, from a completely-unobstructed point of view.
And yet, even though we're looking
directly at the damn thing, in a very well-lit setting, it's
still hard to make proper sense of it against its background.
And the IAA was just one of those things that was
never inclined toward
giving itself away easily. With the IAA, you always had to
fight for understanding with it.
Why a thing like this might be so, I cannot tell you. But it's very definitely the case. Out on the Pad, some things made perfect sense at the merest glance, while other things would
constantly do their dead level best to
throw you off.
A lot of it has to do with the
visuals, but not all of it. Some of it... boy, I don't even know. But some of it just seemed to have this confusingly non-obvious
way about it that caused it to never want to come into clear and crisp conceptual focus.
I do not know. Somebody in the process of getting their degree in the
human perception end of one of the Psychological Disciplines needs to maybe give this some attention, because it has always, both literally and figuratively, baffled me.
Alright.
Let's keep this moving.
And now we're getting somewhere.
And of course Wade Ivey is
right there, standing on top of the front end of the crane's right crawler track, staring close-on to directly straight up, eyes focused on the great mass of the IAA as it closes in on the Connection Plates that it will be bolted to, well over a hundred feet above his head.
At elevation 220'-0", on the top level of the Support Structure which the IAA will attach to, a pair of Union Ironworkers can be seen standing at the edge of a one hundred sixty-seven foot precipice, getting ready to
make the connection, with a third bent over, hands-on with
something, making ready.
Number One, farthest right, is plainly visible, but Number Two, farthest left, is partially obscured by the large and complicated Connection Plate Weldment attached to the FSS Side 1-4 Perimeter Column. He is also rendered less visible by standing in a shadowed area, and shows up only as a partial silhouette. Number Three, bent over, is fully-illuminated, closest to us in between them, partially obscuring them both.
On the ground, behind the crane, another pair of unidentified non-craft-labor operatives are monitoring things, too.
Elsewhere, the entire field of view is deserted, which is as it should be.
Additional ironworkers are on the scene, but none of them need to be out near the
edges of things, and are no doubt gathering tools and equipment, out of view, for the connection bolt-up work which will be getting underway soon.
This isn't what the crane operator is seeing, although it might look that way at first glance.
The "lifting" part of this Lift was essentially over, and I had departed my original position on the east side of the Flame Trench and walked around to the south of it, headed for the FSS Elevators.
Along the way, I passed by the crane, and stopped for a few moments near its left crawler track, just behind it, aimed my camera upward, and grabbed this frame. I'm not
directly under the Lift, but I'm as close as I wanted to get for this one, and from here, I walked on over to the FSS Elevator and hit the button.
From where the crane operator is positioned, sitting in his cab on the right front side of the crane, the boom is completely blocking his view of what's going on over a hundred and fifty feet above him where things are about to go steel-on-steel. At the moment this photograph was taken, he was flying completely blind, solely relying on a stream of instructions being given to him by one of the two Union Ironworkers whose heads you can see, continuing to lean outward for best visibility,
beyond the edge, from their position at elevation 220'-0" on the IAA's Support Structure.
To call this moment in time "dangerous" is to laughably understate it.
One hundred thousand pounds of IAA continues to close in on direct contact with its Support Structure on the FSS, over one hundred fifty feet above where you're seeing it from. A mass like that, even when moving at a snail's pace, carries a
tremendous inertia, and will
very much want to keep right on going, right on
through things, violently bashing, grinding, and crushing them out of its path, with a nightmarishly-fearsome and
uncanny slow motion way about it, as opposed to simply coming to a halt and resting against them with a thud or a clunk. In your own entire life, you've never experienced such a phenomenon,
cannot possibly know a thing about it, and really, you're better off because of it.
Alignment is
crucial, and our unseen ironworker who remains far out of frame to the right, down on the Pad Deck, holding the tag line which controls the rotation of the IAA, needs to be positioned precisely to pull it into the one and only correct orientation prior to making contact with the Connection Plates it will be bolted to.
Maybe take note of the fact that between IAA Column Lines 1.5 and 2 (1.5 which must be
inferred by returning to
79K24048 sheet M-338, because I do not have a set of structural prints for the IAA itself), which is a distance of very roughly fifteen feet, all of the grating panels on the IAA have been
removed, to allow for the connection work that's about to start, and anybody who's out there on that side of things (mandatory, to get the job done), has nothing at all beneath them to impede a fall. It's free and open from there all the way down to the Pad Deck, with maybe a few exceedingly-violent spin-inducing impacts through the
open steel structure on the way down. Maybe give that one a little thought while we're here, ok?
The crane operator works his controls with a surgeon's exquisite accuracy and delicate touch, guiding
one hundred thousand pounds of implacable steel through three dimensions, as if it was a filled-teacup made from fine china, held above a starched white linen tablecloth.
The IAA is now more or less at its final elevation of 220'-0", but it remains very misaligned with the structure it will be attached to, and as with the OMBUU Lift, something has come up (
and as with the OMBUU I never learned what it was), and everything has been brought to a halt until it gets successfully resolved.
And I mentioned, in conjunction with the image of the OMBUU I just referred you back to on Page 64...
"And a fine frame it is, too."
"This one not only gets high marks for "informative", but it also gets high marks for "artistic merit" and "dramatic impact" too."
And as far as I'm concerned, the photograph above these words scores
higher, and it does so in
all three categories.
Dramatic Impact in particular scores exceedingly high with this image, and it might not be for the reason you imagine. It's not just the overall
image. We'll be returning to this item soon enough, but for now it's enough to tell you there's a particular
detail, and that detail is pretty much
off the scale for people who are not
ironworkers, and maybe you'll pick it up on your own, and maybe you won't, but we will
definitely be returning to it, so... stick around.
I consider this to be one of the very best frames I ever got while working at Space Shuttle Launch Complex 39-B. It works exceptionally well on multiple levels, and for me, that's what it's all about.
And what you're seeing in Image 125 right above these words is what was going on when I stepped out of the FSS Elevator at 220'-0", and I immediately realized I had been given the gift of
time, and I seized that gift with both hands and ran up the stairs to the 280'-0" level (
much faster than hitting the button and waiting around for the stupid elevator to show back up), hotfooted it across the grating to the northeast corner of the FSS, sixty feet above the work which had come to a temporary halt beneath me, and up the little stair and
out onto Camera Platform 8
which extends out
beyond the envelope of the FSS to the northeast, to gain a vantage point from which to view things that, I hoped, would allow me to get a few good frames that I otherwise would never have been given a chance to get.
I have been told, on occasion, the above photograph, Image 125, can be a little
confusing for some people. The harsh light and shadow renders much of what's in it impossible to understand for those who have not
studied the material closely. Those who have not yet acquired a fine-grained understanding of the Pad infrastructure that's being shown in the image. Additionally, the bizarre directly-straight-down viewing angle alters the shapes of
everyday objects to the point of opaque incomprehensibility. And on top of that, when viewed from this angle, steel-bar grating panels become
see-through clear, permitting sensible visibility of objects in the distance beneath them, and that can be
surprisingly disorienting, even when you're aware of it in advance. So I decided, in the interests of helping anybody out who might be having any trouble with it, to create a couple of items by way of identifying what we're seeing in this image.
For the first aid in understanding, I went ahead and just
butchered the living hell out of
79K24048 sheet S-115 (which you've already seen, more than once, even) in an effort (no idea how successful) to help with identifying the large-scale layout of where we are and what we're seeing up above these words in Image 125.
And with
that information, we can return to a
labeled version of Image 125, and hopefully gain complete understanding of what we're seeing, and what's going on with it, down to the level of finest detail.
And I mean, yeah, the overall
sense of the photograph is pretty goddamned
obvious... but actually... it's not. There is a
huge amount of stuff going on that looks like some kind of visual
hash. But that's not what's happening...
at all.
Every last bit of that "hash" resolves itself into a level of detail taken, that I still have trouble believing that my little hand-held
Zeiss Ikon Contessa was able to successfully
render it. To a common (for back in the early 1980's) 3½" by 5" paper photographic print, developed at an equally-common (again, for the early 1980's) non-specialty developing operation using a standard commercial developing machine in a little mom-and-pop photography store (thanks be, to Rainbow Photo in Cocoa Beach, Florida, you guys were the
best). And then give that detail right back up, to a computer-controlled flatbed scanning machine all these long decades after it was originally
captured.
For those of us who properly
understand the rarity and priceless-value of what's contained in this (and all the others)
image, about all I can say is...
"We got lucky."
"We got very
very lucky with this stuff."
Nowhere else on earth does it
exist, and nowhere else on earth
will you ever be able to find it. Period. And I may as well take this opportunity to toss in another "Fuck you!" to NASA Public Affairs, and the History Office too, while we're at it, for your truly
astounding level of bovine incomprehension of things your tiny little bureaucratic brains will
never comprehend, and never understand.
And for those who dwell
outside, who
do not, or
can not, understand...
...no worries.
Nobody's ramming anything down anybody's throat with any of this.
It's
here, and it is what it is, and for those with the heart and mind for it...
It's here.
And everybody else gets to go right on doing what they're doing, unimpeded, uninterrupted, unconcerned.
It's all good, ok?
So enough already, so here's the
second item to aid in your understanding of what you're actually looking at.
Here's the same photograph again, Image 125, but this time it's LABELED.
And yeah,
he's labeled too, right along with everything else, but did you happen to
notice that there's a
Union Ironworker in there, and you're looking directly straight down toward the top of his hardhat, and oh yeah, he's
mid-traverse?
Didja catch that little detail?
No?
Then stop reading this and
go find him.
His right hand and foot are on the
crane boom, and his left hand and foot are on the IAA!
In between... the wide-open jaws of
death.
Not
real wide, only about three or four feet or so.
But plenty
wide enough.
Waiting.
And this is the early 1980's, and as was customary for
everyone back then...
No harness, no fall-protection,
no safety gear of any kind except for a hardhat. No
nothing.
Just gloved hands and booted feet on the
iron. One hundred and seventy feet of completely-unimpeded
free drop above the concrete and steel-grid of the Crawlerway beneath him.
And the suspended load is never going to be quite fully, exactly,
still and unmoving. And the crane boom, too.
And you sit there in your chair, with your outstretched hand resting on the desk beside you, imagining it
drifting... imagining it
swaying... just a little... and your chair too... just a little... swaying
independently of the desk... and you think to yourself... "This isn't a big deal. I could do that. How hard could it be?" And of course you are a fool, and have less than no concept at all, as to
what's really going on.
You. Cannot. Imagine.
Ironworking is
RADICAL.
What he's doing, and how he came to be where we see him in this breathtaking image, I have no recall of.
Alas.
The IAA was in an interference condition somehow, and as is generally typical, it's the sort of thing that
ironworkers go right at, with
cutting torches, and...
Yeah, that looks a
lot like a torch lead that's been tossed on to the IAA over there, and I labeled it, too.
What it might have been that would allow for the continuance of the
connection, by lopping it off, I shall never know.
But
something was interfering, or otherwise they would not have
held at this point, waiting for whatever it is to
get resolved. In a shower of molten slag, most likely.
Did he jump across from the FSS? Across the open jaws of death and down on to a projecting thing not much wider than his own boot, unguarded by any handrail or safety net, that will
move beneath his feet when he lands on it?
I do not know.
Did he
climb the crane boom? One hundred and seventy feet? Yes, they really
did that kind of stuff, back in the 1980's, and the Safety People generally turned a blind eye toward it when they did, and the work was allowed to continue, and nobody said anything about it.
I do not know.
But he's
there, and of that there can be not the slightest doubt.
And yeah, the whole thing is pretty fucking
RADICAL.
So now you know why I give this photograph such high marks for
Dramatic Impact.
And if
life and death isn't
dramatic enough for you, well then...
...I dunno what to tell you.
Maybe you should look into getting
examined, perhaps. Maybe you are not as
well-connected with your fellow humans as you
should be, perhaps.
I do not know.
And beyond these words you just read, which themselves are of little to no
real use, there is nothing more that can be constructivley said about any of it.
And the work goes on...
And elsewhere in our labeled photograph...
There is much to see...
Apollo came and went...
And now there is something new, something called a "Space Shuttle," and it will be arriving soon, and the Pad
must be ready for it when it arrives, and the work goes on...
And our labeled photograph allows for comparisons with other labeled photographs, which you can find sprinkled all throughout this narrative, seeing much of what you see here, from ground-level, or other, different, perspectives.
Things look different because of the different point of view, but they also look different because they have changed somewhere along the line.
Image 043, which leads Page 41, demonstrates this, over on its left side where the same Pad Elements can be seen in both images, but it is by no means the only one.
I'll not get into any of the details, but there is much to look for, and find, which is...
different.
And the simple differences in the interplay of light and shadow, of form and composition, are worthy of consideration, too.
And as things turned out, the time dragged on, and the connection process remained on hold, and once I realized I had even
more time, I came back down off of Camera Platform 8, ran across the steel-bar grating of FSS Level 280'-0" to the stair, and went on up, across, and up again, climbing through the open hatchway in the roofing deckplates of the FSS at elevation 300'-0".
And from there, I walked over to the Hammerhead Crane, and out to the end of its boom, approximately 75 feet beyond the edge of the deckplates up there, turned around, found a point of view through the structure of the boom that permitted full visibility, looked back toward the FSS and down, and was greeted by what you see in the photograph above these words.
And from here, despite the fact that you're boots-down on cold hard steel, you may as well be an eagle, wafting along overhead, languidly, looking down, considering, and...
Never in my life shall I ever be able to describe the
sensation.
Never in my life shall I ever be able to describe the
view.
And never in my life shall I ever quit trying to describe
what it's like, anyway.
You can spend a full
decade of your life, scrambling around on
high steel.
And you develop a second-nature sense for it where you become perfectly comfortable with the understanding that it's going to
hold you up.
And you go, and you do, with that second-nature understanding.
Each and every day.
It is your
job after all.
But even so...
There remains several parts of your brain that will detach themselves in
different ways from
the rest of your brain...
Which...
Do not...
Fully
go along with the rest of it...
And the detached senses become
heightened...
And if you're lucky, you may be granted a mote of time in which to...
...consider...
...things...
...from a
different point of view.
And there becomes...
...more than one of you.
And each separate "you"...
...
considers things...
...differently.
And those words I just wrote are pure garbage, of no use whatsoever, and will never convey
anything...
And I shall let them stand, just the same, anyway.
Lingering over the photograph for a bit longer, we're getting a pretty good look at the Flame Trench and the curved Rail Beam that carries the Rotating Service Structure across it, but at this point in the narrative, we've pretty much covered all of the discrete elements which fit together to make up the overall scene.
We've come a
long way since we first walked through Sheffield Steel's field trailer sliding glass doors, back on our first day here at Pad B.
We're now beginning to look at things with the eyes of a seasoned veteran, and that's really cool, and it's really cool,
twice.
Once: Because we have now gained an insider's perspective and
understanding of the place, and that is a perspective and understanding which was not offered to very many souls, back when all of this was in-progress.
And Twice: Because we can, more and more and more, dispense with a strictly
technical understanding of things (it hasn't
gone anywhere, and it's still
right here, but we no longer have to
stare at it to the exclusion of all else), and layer a marvelous topping of aesthetic, artistic, and
perceptual appreciation over that which lives beneath it.
And this is one of the things that seems to get the very
least attention paid to it by... anyone, and I am deeply disinclined to go along with the herd, paying no attention to it for myself.
This thing is a
Wonder of the World, and to shortchange it to the slightest degree on those grounds is to commit a Crime Against
Culture, and...
...no!
And for all you philistines out there tapping your toes impatiently, attempting to brush away the awe-inspiring
ART which this thing embodies...
...well then,
tap away, losers, 'cause you shall never fit your own set of blinders down across my own field of vision, and that goes
treble when my field of vision includes jaw-droppingly, stupefyingly, gobsmackingly
gorgeous and
meaningful things such as what we're seeing here in
Image 126.
This is Human Achievement, capitalized, and is the equal of anything ever designed and built by the Greeks on the Acropolis, the Egyptians in Giza, or the still-unknown neolithics out on the Plain of Salisbury.
With the exception being that those Ancient Wonders
still stand, whereas The Towers of Pad B are
gone. Forever. Destroyed for all time,
by their own creators. And all we will ever have, going forward, is a pitiful store of images and stories, most of which,
created by NASA Officialdom, are as without life as the dried mummy of an Egyptian laborer, covered in dust, found within the broken stones of a long-forgotten crypt.
NASA
HATES the Artistic element of what they're doing, and I hold a strong suspicion that it's because
every last one of them was selected for their positions in the organization based on
technical merit, whether needed or not, and the
first cull for every single job applicant was one of sweeping aside
every singe one of the people with proper
artistic and
cultural training, and the results bear this out to me, far beyond the shadow of a doubt.
The stupid sonofabitches
don't get it, and they don't want
you to get it either, because the extent to which you
do get it, is the extent to which it
makes them look bad.
Philistines. One and all.
And the best they can do is to put on happy-face masks, and try to enthuse about third-grade-show-and-tell
garbage, believing themselves successful at...
outreach.
Buncha goddamned bullshit, is what it is. The whole thing.
Which of course is heartbreaking in the extreme, but in this instance, the inmates have well and truly taken over the asylum, and people like me (and you) on the
outside can hold no hope of things ever
coming around.
So ok, so Fuck You, NASA organization droids,
I'll do the motherfucker myself, and I'll do a job that the likes of you stunted homunculi could never so much as even
imagine.
And so I have, and so I shall.
Look again, at the arc of that Rail Beam.
Look again, at the light and shadow of the great features of the Flame Trench.
Look again, at that tiny crane cab in the depths far below you, with a boom extending
right at you, up and beyond the top of the frame.
Look again at the
broken symmetry of the IAA, white, with its Blast Shield reaching outward to the left, above the mystifyingly-complex and jarringly-modernistic
jazz composition of its structure, light and dark, light and dark, light and dark, fully self-contained and without need to explain itself to you, or anybody else.
Look again, at the
tiny people on the Tower, considering the
notes which are being
played.
Look again, at the
sole individual, standing on the concrete behind the crane, casting a legs-apart shadow, giving
scale, giving a sense of the Greatness of it all.
Look at the fucking thing!
Look at it.
With eyes that
see.
With a heart, and a soul, and a
spirit that sees.
And do not try to
understand any of it.
Just
feel it.
Just
feel the goddamned thing.
And for those of you who can do this...
...
know that you have been...
...
gifted.
And for those of you who
cannot...
Great lamentations and sorrow is all I will ever be able to offer any of you, and I can only hope that...
one day... you too...
...
might.